Skip to content
Just added to your cart
Qty:
View cart (
)
Continue shopping
Submit
Close search
Help Keep Art Alive
Search
Log in
Cart
0
items
Home
Shop
Shop Menu
Shop
Shop All
Cuddly Creatures All
Freaks
Geeks
Black Sheep
Black Sheep Menu
Black Sheep
Tarot Cards
90s Babes
Coraline
Enamel Pins
Apparel
Patterns
About
Home
Shop
Shop All
Cuddly Creatures All
Freaks
Geeks
Black Sheep
Tarot Cards
90s Babes
Coraline
Enamel Pins
Apparel
Patterns
About
Collection:
Cuddly Creatures All
Filter by
All products
$5
666
666 keychain
80s horror
90's
90s
90s baby
adopt a Cthulhu
adopt a rainbow Cthulhu
albino
Albino baphomet
albino rabbit
Alice in wonderland
alien
Alien vs predator
Apple
baby Baphomet
Baby Beatles
baby blue
Baphomet
Baphomet keychain
Beatles
bedtime
bedtime care bear
bedtime care goat
Beetlejuice
Beetlejuice and lydia
Big Boy Sam
black cat
black Christmas
black goat
black sheep
black tree
Bulbasaur
Bulbasaur goat
bunny
candy corn
care bear
Care-thulhu
cartoon
cartoon characters
Cartoon Network
cat
chenille Baphomet
Christmas
Christmas Baphomet
Christmas goat
Christmas hood
Christmas tree
clown
Cocoa goat keychain
Coraline
Coraline box
Coraline doll
Coraline squid
corpse bride
courage
courage the cowardly dog
courage the cowardly dog plush
Courage the cowardly goat
creature
Cthulhu
cuddly
Cuddly deadpool
cuddly Sam
custom Nessie
custom order
custom order Nessie
dead
dead mushroom
Deadpool
demented
demon
devil
devil bear
devil teddy
Disney
Disney villain
Dr suess
Easter
Emily
Emily the corpse bride
Emo
enamel pin
enamel pins
Eve the goat
Ewok
Flowers
freak
freaks
Friday the 13th
Garden goat
geek
geeks
ghost face
Ghostface
gir
Gir goat
GirPhomet
gloomy bear
Gloomy goat
goat
Goat keychain
Goth buddy bunny
grass type
green
Green goat
grey
Grinch
grumps
grumps the sphynx cat
grumpy
grumpy Care Bear
Hail satan eat pizza
hairless cat
Halloween
Harry Potter
holiday
horror
horror fan
horror movie
horror movie plush
hot pink
hot pink Ghostface
ice cream
Ice cream goat
Invader Moose…the Goat
invader zim
it
jack
Jack and sally
Jack skellington
Jack the pumpkin king
Jason
Jason vorhees
keychain
killer Klown
killer Klown from outer space
Killer Klowns
Killer Klowns from Outer Space
Kitten
kitty
Lenny the sea creature
lgbtq
little boy goat
lollipop
lore
lure
Maleficent
Mandrake
Mandrake goat
Mario
mario and Luigi
Mario life
Marvel
Medium goat
metal Christmas tree
mini goat
Moose
moth
moth man
mothman
mr CandyHorn
Mummy
mushroom
mushroom life
Mushroomhead
mystery
mystery box
mystery Coraline
mystery Sam
myth
mythical creature
nerd
nerdy
Nessie
Nickelodeon
nightmare before Christmas
Nintendo
oogie boogie
Opossum
Oppossum
orange
orange and tan
pastel
pastel horror
pennywise
pennywise the dancing clown
pentagram
pickle
pickle rock
pink
pink horror
Piranha plant
Piranha plant goat
Pizza
Plankton
poisoned apple
poisoned candy apple
pokemon
Poor little white rabbit
Possum
preorder
preorder Ghostface
Pretty n pink goat
psychic duck
Psyduck
pumpkin
pumpkin king
Pumpkin kitten
purple
purple bear
Pysho
rabbit
Radioactive rabbit
rainbow
rainbow Cthulhu
Rainbow goat
Rainbow pj goat
red
red and black
red mushroom
retro stripe
Rick
Rick and morty
Sam
Sam doll
Sam trick r treat
Satan
satanic
satanist
scare bear
scare bears
sea creature
sea monster
share care bear
share care goat
Sherpa goat
Shorty the Killer Goat
Shorty the Killer Goat Clown
shorty the Klown
Shrek
skelanimal
skeleton
skully the Bear
slasher
soft
sparkle
Sparkles the Baphomet
sphinx
sphynx
Spirit of Halloween
Spongebob
Spongebob squarepants
Star Wars
Stephen king
super Mario
Superhero
surprise
teddy
teddy bear
The grinch
the satanic temple
The white rabbit
Tim burton
trick or treat
trick r treat
tst
valentine
Valentine's Day
velvet
video game
video games
villain
villainous bag of bugs
Vintage
Vintage cartoon
Vintage psycho
white
white rabbit
wizard
Xenomorph
Xmen
yoshi
Sort by
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
93 products
Devil Teddy Scare Bear
Devil Teddy Scare Bear
Regular price
$84.99
Sale price
$84.99
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Sale
Sold out
Skully the Scare Bear
Skully the Scare Bear
Regular price
$74.99
Sale price
$74.99
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Sale
Sold out
Hot Pink Ghostface
Hot Pink Ghostface
Regular price
$84.99
Sale price
$84.99
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Sale
Sold out
Bedtime Care Goat
Bedtime Care Goat
Regular price
$49.99
Sale price
$49.99
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Sale
Sold out
Grumpy Care Goat
Grumpy Care Goat
Regular price
$49.99
Sale price
$49.99
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Sale
Sold out
Christmas Goat
Christmas Goat
Regular price
$99.99
Sale price
$99.99
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Sale
Sold out
Metal Christmas Tree
Metal Christmas Tree
Regular price
$19.99
Sale price
$19.99
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Sale
Sold out
Mothman
Mothman
Regular price
$59.99
Sale price
$59.99
Regular price
Unit price
/
per
Sale
Sold out
Previous page
Page 10 of 12
Next page
Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection.
